GATE 2015 ME Set 3 · Question 7
Given below are two statements followed by two conclusions. Assuming these statements to be true, decide which one logically follows.
Statements:
I. No manager is a leader.
II. All leaders are executives.
Conclusions:
I. No manager is an executive.
II. No executive is a manager.
- A
Only conclusion I follows.
- B
Only conclusion II follows.
- C
Neither conclusion I nor II follows.
- D
Both conclusions I and II follow.
GATE 2015 · Mechanical Engineering · Set 3 · IIT Kanpur
Answer
From the official answer key published by IIT Kanpur.
Worked solution
Let the sets of managers, leaders, and executives be denoted by , , and , respectively.
The given premises are:
1. No manager is a leader: (the sets of managers and leaders are disjoint).
2. All leaders are executives: (the set of leaders is entirely contained within the set of executives).
We evaluate the conclusions:
- Conclusion I (No manager is an executive, i.e., ): While no manager can be part of , the set of executives can be larger than . The region may or may not overlap with . Since it is possible that some executives are managers, Conclusion I does not necessarily follow.
- Conclusion II (No executive is a manager, i.e., ): This is the converse of Conclusion I and similarly does not necessarily follow.
Since neither conclusion is guaranteed by the premises, neither follows.
Answer: (C) Neither conclusion I nor II follows.
Practise Analytical Aptitude: Logic, Clocks, Calendars and Reasoning
49 GATE questions from this chapter, in short untimed sets, with the formula sheet beside them. Free.
More from Analytical Aptitude: Logic, Clocks, Calendars and Reasoning
- GATE 2014 ME Set 1 · Q2Read the statements: All women are entrepreneurs. Some women are doctors. Which of the following conclusions…
- GATE 2014 ME Set 1 · Q6Find the odd one from the following group: W,E,K,O I,Q,W,A F,N,T,X N,V,B,D
- GATE 2014 ME Set 1 · Q7For submitting tax returns, all resident males with annual income below Rs 10 lakh should fill up Form P and…
- GATE 2014 ME Set 2 · Q6Find the odd one in the following group Q,W,Z,B B,H,K,M W,C,G,J M,S,V,X
- GATE 2014 ME Set 2 · Q7Lights of four colors (red, blue, green, yellow) are hung on a ladder. On every step of the ladder there are…
- GATE 2014 ME Set 3 · Q5In which of the following options will the expression P < M be definitely true?
Question from the official GATE 2015 ME paper (Set 3), IIT Kanpur. Solutions by PARIXO AI. All 65 questions of this paper.