PARIXO GATE · ME Open the app

GATE 2019 ME Set 1 · Question 6

2 marksMultiple choiceGeneral AptitudeAnalytical Aptitude: Logic, Clocks, Calendars and Reasoning

Under a certain legal system, prisoners are allowed to make one statement. If their statement turns out to be true then they are hanged. If the statement turns out to be false then they are shot. One prisoner made a statement and the judge had no option but to set him free. Which one of the following could be that statement?

  1. A

    I did not commit the crime

  2. B

    I committed the crime

  3. C

    I will be shot

  4. D

    You committed the crime

GATE 2019 · Mechanical Engineering · Set 1 · IIT Madras · printed as Q.6 in the GA section

Answer
(C)

From the official answer key published by IIT Madras.

Worked solution

Let the prisoner's statement be : "I will be shot".

1. Suppose is true. According to the rules, a true statement implies the prisoner must be hanged. However, if he is hanged, then the statement "I will be shot" becomes false, which is a logical contradiction.
2. Suppose is false. The rules state that a false statement implies the prisoner must be shot. But if he is shot, the statement "I will be shot" becomes true, which again is a logical contradiction.

Because executing either punishment creates an unsolvable paradox (the classic Crocodilite or liar-type paradox), the judge cannot lawfully hang or shoot him, leaving no option but to set him free.

Statements (A), (B), and (D) are factual claims about crimes that can be definitively true or false without creating a self-referential paradox.

Answer: (C) I will be shot

Practise Analytical Aptitude: Logic, Clocks, Calendars and Reasoning

49 GATE questions from this chapter, in short untimed sets, with the formula sheet beside them. Free.

More from Analytical Aptitude: Logic, Clocks, Calendars and Reasoning

Question from the official GATE 2019 ME paper (Set 1), IIT Madras. Solutions by PARIXO AI. All 65 questions of this paper.