PARIXO GATE · ME Open the app

GATE 2015 ME Set 1 · Question 7

2 marksMultiple choiceGeneral AptitudeAnalytical Aptitude: Logic, Clocks, Calendars and Reasoning

Given below are two statements followed by two conclusions. Assuming these statements to be true, decide which one logically follows.

Statements:
I. All film stars are playback singers.
II. All film directors are film stars.

Conclusions:
I. All film directors are playback singers.
II. Some film stars are film directors.

  1. A

    Only conclusion I follows.

  2. B

    Only conclusion II follows.

  3. C

    Neither conclusion I nor II follows.

  4. D

    Both conclusions I and II follow.

GATE 2015 · Mechanical Engineering · Set 1 · IIT Kanpur

Answer
(D)

From the official answer key published by IIT Kanpur.

Worked solution

Represent the statements using set notation:

  • Statement I:
  • Statement II:

Combining these inclusions:

Now, evaluate the conclusions:
1. Conclusion I: "All film directors are playback singers." Since , this conclusion logically follows.
2. Conclusion II: "Some film stars are film directors." Since all film directors are film stars, the set intersection of film stars and film directors is non-empty. Thus, by subalternation (conversion of universal affirmative statement), it logically follows that some film stars are film directors.

Therefore, both conclusions I and II follow.

Answer: (D) Both conclusions I and II follow.

Practise Analytical Aptitude: Logic, Clocks, Calendars and Reasoning

49 GATE questions from this chapter, in short untimed sets, with the formula sheet beside them. Free.

More from Analytical Aptitude: Logic, Clocks, Calendars and Reasoning

Question from the official GATE 2015 ME paper (Set 1), IIT Kanpur. Solutions by PARIXO AI. All 65 questions of this paper.