PARIXO GATE · ME Open the app

GATE 2019 ME Set 2 · Question 8

2 marksMultiple choiceGeneral AptitudeVerbal Aptitude

While teaching a creative writing class in India, I was surprised at receiving stories from the students that were all set in distant places: in the American West with cowboys and in Manhattan penthouses with clinking ice cubes. This was, till an eminent Caribbean writer gave the writers in the once-colonised countries the confidence to see the shabby lives around them as worthy of being “told”.

The writer of this passage is surprised by the creative writing assignments of his students, because ________.

  1. A

    Some of the students had written stories set in foreign places

  2. B

    None of the students had written stories set in India

  3. C

    None of the students had written about ice cubes and cowboys

  4. D

    Some of the students had written about ice cubes and cowboys

GATE 2019 · Mechanical Engineering · Set 2 · IIT Madras · printed as Q.8 in the GA section

Answer
(B)

From the official answer key published by IIT Madras.

Worked solution

The passage states: "...teaching a creative writing class in India, I was surprised at receiving stories from the students that were all set in distant places..."

Because the class was located in India and the stories submitted by the students were *all* set in foreign environments (such as the American West or Manhattan), it directly implies that not a single student chose to set their story in their native setting, India.

The author's surprise stemmed from the fact that students in India did not see their immediate surroundings as worthy of being written about until prompted by the Caribbean writer. Therefore, none of the students had written stories set in India.

  • Options (A) and (D) are incorrect because it was "all" students, not merely "some".
  • Option (C) contradicts the passage, which explicitly mentions stories about cowboys and ice cubes.

Answer: (B) None of the students had written stories set in India

Practise Verbal Aptitude

97 GATE questions from this chapter, in short untimed sets, with the formula sheet beside them. Free.

More from Verbal Aptitude

Question from the official GATE 2019 ME paper (Set 2), IIT Madras. Solutions by PARIXO AI. All 65 questions of this paper.