PARIXO GATE · ME Open the app

GATE 2014 ME Set 3 · Question 20

1 markMultiple choiceMechanics of MaterialsEnergy Methods and Theories of Failure

Which one of following is NOT correct?

  1. A

    Intermediate principal stress is ignored when applying the maximum principal stress theory

  2. B

    The maximum shear stress theory gives the most accurate results amongst all the failure theories

  3. C

    As per the maximum strain energy theory, failure occurs when the strain energy per unit volume exceeds a critical value

  4. D

    As per the maximum distortion energy theory, failure occurs when the distortion energy per unit volume exceeds a critical value

GATE 2014 · Mechanical Engineering · Set 3 · IIT Kharagpur · printed as Q.10 in the ME section

Answer
(B)

From the official answer key published by IIT Kharagpur.

Worked solution

Let us evaluate the statements:

  • (A) is correct: The Maximum Principal Stress Theory (Rankine's theory) assumes failure occurs when the absolute maximum principal stress reaches the yield strength, completely neglecting the intermediate and minimum principal stresses.
  • (B) is NOT correct: The Maximum Shear Stress Theory (Tresca's theory) is conservative and safe for design, but the Maximum Distortion Energy Theory (von Mises theory) provides the most accurate and best agreement with experimental results for ductile materials.
  • (C) is correct: Haigh's theory (Maximum Strain Energy Theory) posits that yielding begins when the total strain energy per unit volume reaches the strain energy per unit volume at the yield point in simple tension.
  • (D) is correct: The Distortion Energy Theory (von Mises–Hencky theory) states that failure occurs when shear strain energy (distortion energy) per unit volume reaches that at yield in uniaxial tension.

Hence, statement (B) is the incorrect statement.

Answer: (B) The maximum shear stress theory gives the most accurate results amongst all the failure theories

Practise Energy Methods and Theories of Failure

21 GATE questions from this chapter, in short untimed sets, with the formula sheet beside them. Free.

More from Energy Methods and Theories of Failure

Question from the official GATE 2014 ME paper (Set 3), IIT Kharagpur. Solutions by PARIXO AI. All 65 questions of this paper.