PARIXO GATE · ME Open the app

GATE 2023 ME · Question 17

1 markMultiple choiceEngineering MechanicsTrusses and Frames

The options show frames consisting of rigid bars connected by pin joints. Which one of the frames is non-rigid?

Figure 1 for GATE 2023 ME question 17Figure 2 for GATE 2023 ME question 17Figure 3 for GATE 2023 ME question 17Figure 4 for GATE 2023 ME question 17
  1. A

    See figure (A)

  2. B

    See figure (B)

  3. C

    See figure (C)

  4. D

    See figure (D)

GATE 2023 · Mechanical Engineering · IIT Kanpur

Answer
(C)

From the official answer key published by IIT Kanpur.

Worked solution

A plane frame consisting of pin-jointed bars must satisfy the necessary condition for static determinacy and rigidity, but also its members must be arranged to prevent any internal mechanism (all sub-panels must be rigid triangles or adequately triangulated).

In Figure (C), the structure has three panels:

  • The left panel has a diagonal brace, forming two rigid triangles.
  • The right panel has an internal joint with braces forming four triangles, making it locally rigid.
  • However, the middle panel is a four-bar linkage (quadrilateral) with no diagonal bracing.

Because the middle panel lacks a diagonal member, it can deform into a parallelogram without altering any member lengths. Thus, the frame possesses an internal degree of freedom and is non-rigid (collapsible).

In contrast, Figures (A), (B), and (D) are fully triangulated, ensuring complete rigidity.

Answer: (C) See figure (C)

Practise Trusses and Frames

21 GATE questions from this chapter, in short untimed sets, with the formula sheet beside them. Free.

More from Trusses and Frames

Question from the official GATE 2023 ME paper, IIT Kanpur. Solutions by PARIXO AI. All 65 questions of this paper.