GATE 2023 ME · Question 17
The options show frames consisting of rigid bars connected by pin joints. Which one of the frames is non-rigid?
- A
See figure (A)
- B
See figure (B)
- C
See figure (C)
- D
See figure (D)
GATE 2023 · Mechanical Engineering · IIT Kanpur
Answer
From the official answer key published by IIT Kanpur.
Worked solution
A plane frame consisting of pin-jointed bars must satisfy the necessary condition for static determinacy and rigidity, but also its members must be arranged to prevent any internal mechanism (all sub-panels must be rigid triangles or adequately triangulated).
In Figure (C), the structure has three panels:
- The left panel has a diagonal brace, forming two rigid triangles.
- The right panel has an internal joint with braces forming four triangles, making it locally rigid.
- However, the middle panel is a four-bar linkage (quadrilateral) with no diagonal bracing.
Because the middle panel lacks a diagonal member, it can deform into a parallelogram without altering any member lengths. Thus, the frame possesses an internal degree of freedom and is non-rigid (collapsible).
In contrast, Figures (A), (B), and (D) are fully triangulated, ensuring complete rigidity.
Answer: (C) See figure (C)
Practise Trusses and Frames
21 GATE questions from this chapter, in short untimed sets, with the formula sheet beside them. Free.
More from Trusses and Frames
- GATE 2022 ME Set 1 · Q49A structure, along with the loads applied on it, is shown in the figure. Self-weight of all the members is…
- GATE 2022 ME Set 2 · Q47The lengths of members BC and CE in the frame shown in the figure are equal. All the members are rigid and…
- GATE 2021 ME Set 2 · Q24A plane truss PQRS (PQ = RS, and PQR = 90°) is shown in the figure. The forces in the members PR and RS,…
- GATE 2020 ME Set 1 · Q15The members carrying zero force (i.e. zero-force members) in the truss shown in the figure, for any load P >…
- GATE 2020 ME Set 1 · Q51The magnitude of reaction force at joint C of the hinge-beam shown in the figure is ________ kN *(round off…
- GATE 2019 ME Set 1 · Q48A truss is composed of members AB, BC, CD, AD and BD, as shown in the figure. A vertical load of 10 kN is…
Question from the official GATE 2023 ME paper, IIT Kanpur. Solutions by PARIXO AI. All 65 questions of this paper.