GATE 2015 ME Set 1 · Question 29
Which one of the following is the most conservative fatigue failure criterion?
- A
Soderberg
- B
Modified Goodman
- C
ASME Elliptic
- D
Gerber
GATE 2015 · Mechanical Engineering · Set 1 · IIT Kanpur
Answer
From the official answer key published by IIT Kanpur.
Worked solution
Under fluctuating loads, various failure criteria relate the alternating stress amplitude and mean stress to material strengths:
1. Soderberg line:
2. Modified Goodman line:
3. ASME Elliptic:
4. Gerber parabola:
Here, is the endurance limit, is the yield strength, and is the ultimate tensile strength. Because , the Soderberg line intersects the mean stress axis at the lowest value () and follows a straight line. Thus, it encompasses the smallest safe region on the Haigh diagram, making it the most conservative criterion against both fatigue failure and static yielding.
Answer: (A) Soderberg
Practise Design for Dynamic Loading & Fatigue
19 GATE questions from this chapter, in short untimed sets, with the formula sheet beside them. Free.
More from Design for Dynamic Loading & Fatigue
- GATE 2015 ME Set 3 · Q11For the given fluctuating fatigue load, the values of stress amplitude and stress ratio are respectively
- GATE 2014 ME Set 2 · Q20In a structure subjected to fatigue loading, the minimum and maximum stresses developed in a cycle are 200…
- GATE 2014 ME Set 3 · Q16A rotating steel shaft is supported at the ends. It is subjected to a point load at the center. The maximum…
- GATE 2013 ME · Q40A bar is subjected to fluctuating tensile load from 20 kN to 100 kN. The material has yield strength of 240…
- GATE 2025 ME · Q43The endurance limit of a specific grade of steel is same as its yield strength. The ultimate strength of…
- GATE 2024 ME · Q26Which one of the following failure theories is the most conservative design approach against fatigue failure?
Question from the official GATE 2015 ME paper (Set 1), IIT Kanpur. Solutions by PARIXO AI. All 65 questions of this paper.